4.87 from 15 votes (14 ratings without comment)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating




6 Comments

  1. 5 stars
    I have being making them for years. My grandkids and kids love love them . it is their ultimate favorite cookie and i frost them with lemon and powdered sugar. Mix juice lemon with the powder sugar and they come out so good and dunk the front of the cookie. I don’t use better, I use melted Crisco one cup, and I also put 4 teaspoons of vanilla in 4 lemons zest.

  2. We made these cookies when I was a kid. My mother used the grinder with a special star tip that my father made. We made a ton of them. One of us cranked while the other one cut. It was a lot of work, but everyone loved them. It was one of our main cookies at Christmas. I lost her recipe, so I will soon try yours. My mother was half Sicilian and half Napleton.

  3. I tried this recipe yesterday, the mix was to dry. Added 2 more eggs & 2 Tbs. Of milk, to get it right. Can you please check the ingredients. Thanks. Diane

    1. Hi Diane, I've been making this recipe for a long time and the amounts should be correct. Did you follow the gram or US measurements? What flour did you use? Did you use large eggs? Apologies for the many questions, just trying to understand what went wrong 🙂

  4. Love S cookies . Can’t wait to try this recipe .
    Can you provide the recipe of the piped S cookies that are in the photo as well ? TIA

    1. Hi Jaqueline can't wait to hear how you liked them! The recipe to make the piped cookies is the same, I simply added the optional 1 tablespoon of milk. However, I don't recommend piping the cookies, it's very hard! You'll need a good piping bag (not the disposable ones), and you need to press very hard. I do however recommend the traditional method mentioned in the post, and use the cookie cutter attachment for a mincer (there's a link in the post for the cookie attachment, it should work also with the Kitchen Aid mincer attchment).