4.67 from 3 votes (2 ratings without comment)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating




4 Comments

  1. Oh my gosh. Wow, anyone who has to leave such an arrogant 'comment' that they are second generation (who cares??) that you don't know what you're talking about and need to do the recipe over.

    Has never really been to Ireland! I LIVE there. LOL!! We're also talking about CREATIVE license as a chef. FULLY acceptable and agreeable.

    GORGEOUS recipe, The only thing I would make sure to leave chunks/cubes of potatoes. I like a more hearty/earthy soup (not a soupy soup, if that makes sense?) Fabulous site (This recipe is *just fine*)

  2. Someone got creative with the copy here. A traditional New England clam chowder inspired by a trip to Dublin? I'm second gen irish American and grew up in Connecticut. This recipe misses a traditional clam chowder by a mile.tomato is for Manhattan style .Chowder and never finds its way into a traditional New England pot. Garlic? Really?
    I like this site and often pull inspiration from it. This recipe is a do over.for the record new England is Connecticut,Massachusetts,Vermont,New Hampshire and Maine. Take a road trip.

    1. Hi John, thank you for your raw comments :). I've never said it was a traditional meal from Ireland. I've only said I discovered it while on holiday in Dublin, which I'm sure you know is full of international restaurants, including american-style ones where I got to try this recipe. Unfortunately I've never been to US, but it doesn't mean I don't know where New England is.
      I've also never said there should be tomato, but I gave the option because it's a nice addition. Could you please be more specific when you say this is FAR from being a traditional chowder? There are no tomatoes, and I'm quite sure garlic is listed in the original recipe too. So let me know if there's anything else wrong so I can improve myself and share a loyal recipe to the original. Have a nice weekend 🙂